The study made news--see, for example, this piece in the New York Times. But do the results really mean that antidepressants are ineffective? I don't think so. In order to understand the implications of the study, you have to understand how clinical trials are conducted, and how radically they differ from usual care.
Neuron Culture
David Dobbs on science, nature, and culture.
Search
Profile
I write on science, medicine, nature, culture and other matters for the New York Times Magazine, The Atlantic, Slate, National Geographic, Scientific American Mind, and other publications. (Find clips here.)
I've also written three books, including Reef Madness: Charles Darwin, Alexander Agassiz, and the Meaning of Coral, which traces the strangest but most forgotten controversy in Darwin's career — an elemental dispute running some 75 years. Oliver Sacks found Reef Madness "brilliantly written, almost unbearably poignant." Check it out.
If you'd like, you can subscribe to Neuron Culture by email. You might also want to see more of my work at my main website or check out my Tumblr log.
My Google Shared links
Recent Posts
- Ezra Klein - America spends way, way, way more on health care
- NEJM study finds post-event morphine cuts combat PTSD rates in half
- Rebooting science journalism -mixed-metaphor notes on the upcoming yakfest
- Danny Carlat on the big new antidepressants-don't-work study
- Neuron Culture's top five from December
- Avatar smackdown!
- Winning ugly, but winning
- Is this where Gladwell wanders astray?
- Sell the drugs, they pay you. Criticize the drugs, they sue you.
- Rebooting science journalism, redux
Recent Comments
- Katharine on NEJM study finds post-event morphine cuts combat PTSD rates in half
- Matt on The Weird History of Vaccine Adjuvants
- Aaron Huertas on Rebooting science journalism -mixed-metaphor notes on the upcoming yakfest
- P. Jennings on Rebooting science journalism -mixed-metaphor notes on the upcoming yakfest
- John Timmer on Rebooting science journalism -mixed-metaphor notes on the upcoming yakfest
- Karl on Avatar smackdown!
- Malayna Dawn on Does the "orchid-dandelion" metaphor work for you? My duel with David Shenk
- David Dobbs on Rebooting (and Funding) Science Journalism
- Christopher Mims on Rebooting (and Funding) Science Journalism
- r4 on Vaughan Bell on kicking the addiction habit. Get your fix!
Categories
- Art
- Books
- Brains and minds
- Culture of science
- Digital culture
- Economics
- Education
- Environment/nature
- Evolution
- Food and Drink
- Healthcare policy
- History/philosophy of science
- Interesting if true...
- Journalism
- Matters military
- Media
- Medicine
- Music
- Neuroethics
- Nota Bene
- Orchids & Dandelions (behav genetics)
- PTSD
- Pharma
- Politics
- Psychiatry
- Reading
- Science
- Science policy
- Sports
- Swine flu
- Writing
« Neuron Culture's top five from December | Main | Rebooting science journalism -mixed-metaphor notes on the upcoming yakfest »
Danny Carlat on the big new antidepressants-don't-work study
Posted on: January 8, 2010 9:05 AM, by David Dobbs
Share this: Facebook Twitter Stumbleupon Reddit Email + More
TrackBacks
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://scienceblogs.com/mt/pings/128774